Selle Italia X1 Saddle Review: Comfort and Performance for Shorter Rides

Updated at: 20/03/2025

This review delves into the Selle Italia X1 saddle, a stock component often found on budget-friendly mountain bikes. We'll examine its performance and comfort levels, focusing on its suitability for various riding durations and intensities. The X1's minimalist design and lack of extensive padding are key aspects that will be explored, determining its overall effectiveness for different cyclists.This assessment will cover both the positive and negative experiences with the X1. We'll assess its adequacy for shorter rides and contrast this with its limitations during extended periods in the saddle. Ultimately, we will determine whether this budget-friendly option provides acceptable comfort and support, and if it's a suitable choice for casual riders versus those engaged in more serious or longer cycling endeavors. A final rating will be provided to help readers make informed purchasing decisions.

Read more: The 5 Best Bike Saddles for Triathlons

Initial Impressions and Packaging

The Selle Italia X1 arrived as the stock saddle on my Opus Prime 2.0 mountain bike. It's a basic, OEM product, meaning it's not sold in retail packaging. This suggests a lower price point and potentially simpler construction than higher-end models.

Close-up shot of the Selle Italia X1 saddle.
Close-up shot of the Selle Italia X1 saddle.

First impressions were of a fairly minimalist design. There wasn't an abundance of extra padding or features.

Shot showcasing the saddle's simple, unbranded packaging (or lack thereof).
Shot showcasing the saddle's simple, unbranded packaging (or lack thereof).

Comfort and Ride Experience

During shorter rides (20-30 minutes), the X1 was adequate. However, longer rides revealed its major drawback: insufficient cushioning. The lack of padding made it uncomfortable for extended periods.

The reviewer pressing on the saddle to demonstrate the lack of cushioning.
The reviewer pressing on the saddle to demonstrate the lack of cushioning.

Pressure points quickly became apparent, and my bottom felt noticeably sore after longer outings. This led me to replace it with a more comfortable alternative.

The reviewer showing their preferred replacement saddle.
The reviewer showing their preferred replacement saddle.

Overall Assessment and Value

The Selle Italia X1 is a budget-friendly option that's perfectly acceptable for short rides and casual cycling. However, its lack of cushioning makes it unsuitable for longer distances or more intense rides.

The reviewer giving his overall assessment of the saddle.
The reviewer giving his overall assessment of the saddle.

Considering its price point and intended use as original equipment, it's not a bad saddle. But for serious cyclists who prioritize comfort, it's essential to look for something with significantly more padding and support. Overall, this saddle receives a 5/10 rating.

The reviewer mentioning his limited use of the saddle before switching.
The reviewer mentioning his limited use of the saddle before switching.

Final Verdict and Recommendation

I'm giving this Selle Italia X1 a 5/10 rating. While it's adequate for short rides or casual use, the lack of cushioning and resulting discomfort during longer rides are significant drawbacks.

The reviewer concluding his mini-review.
The reviewer concluding his mini-review.

If you're looking for a comfortable saddle for longer distances or more strenuous activities, I highly recommend exploring other options with more padding and ergonomic designs. This saddle is ultimately better suited for riders with shorter commutes or less demanding rides.