This review pits two 3D-printed saddles against each other: the budget-friendly Ryet ($38) and the premium Fizik ($300). Both utilize innovative 3D printing for comfort and weight reduction, but their materials, construction, and overall feel differ significantly, reflecting their price disparity. We put both saddles through a two-week, 100-mile test ride to assess comfort, weight, and overall performance. This comparison explores the trade-offs between affordability and high-end features, helping cyclists decide which saddle best suits their needs and budget.Our detailed analysis covers various aspects, including packaging, material quality, construction, weight, dimensions, and riding experience. We examine the differences in saddle shape and its impact on rider positioning and pressure distribution. Ultimately, we offer a comprehensive comparison to guide you towards making an informed decision, considering your individual preferences for comfort, weight, and price point, ultimately determining whether the premium Fizik justifies its significantly higher cost over the surprisingly capable Ryet.
Pros And Cons
- Lightweight (143g)
- Relatively inexpensive ($38)
- Good return policy on AliExpress
- Less material, potentially less comfortable for some
- Steeper angle may not be suitable for all riders
- Width may be limited (around 143mm)
- More comfortable due to more material
- Flatter saddle angle
- Higher quality build (handmade in Italy)
- More expensive ($300, but can be found used or on sale)
- Heavier (220g)
Read more: The 5 Best Bike Saddles for Triathlons
Unboxing and Initial Impressions: Ryet 3D Printed Saddle
The Ryet saddle arrived quickly in its simple AliExpress packaging. The box opens to reveal the saddle encased in plastic. First impressions are positive; it feels lightweight and well-constructed for its price point.
The saddle boasts a full carbon base and 7x9 carbon rails. The 3D-printed design is evident, with a noticeable cutout in the center for pressure relief. The blue Ryet logo adds a touch of branding.
The 3D-printed material feels surprisingly soft, yielding easily to pressure. The thickness varies across the saddle, being thinner at the nose and thicker in the central support area. The overall construction seems solid and free of significant imperfections.
Unboxing and Initial Impressions: Fizik Anares Versus Evo R1 Saddle
The Fizik saddle arrived in more substantial packaging than the Ryet. This saddle features a carbon reinforced nylon shell with alloy rails, a noticeable upgrade from the Ryet's all-carbon construction.
The 3D-printed material on the Fizik feels firmer, especially in the central area, with a softer texture on the outer wings. The build quality is exceptional, as expected from a premium brand. It's handmade in Italy and bears the Fizik branding prominently.
The Fizik saddle's cutout design is more subtle than the Ryet's; it has a different aesthetic appeal, and the overall feel is more substantial and luxurious.
Comparison: Size, Weight, and Saddle Shape
The Ryet saddle's dimensions are approximately 140-143mm wide, while the Fizik offers sizes up to 149mm, making the Fizik a potentially better option for riders needing a wider saddle.
Weight is another key differentiator: the Ryet weighs in at a surprisingly light 143g, whereas the Fizik is significantly heavier at 220g. The weight difference is largely attributed to the materials used and overall construction.
The saddle shapes differ. The Ryet has a more pronounced angled shape, while the Fizik is flatter overall and only angles up subtly at the rear. These differences impact rider positioning and pressure distribution.
Riding Experience and Personal Preference
After two weeks of riding both saddles (approximately 100 miles each), my preference leans towards the Fizik. The increased padding and wider contact area significantly reduced pressure points on my sit bones.
The Fizik's flatter profile and less aggressive rearward angle provided a more comfortable riding posture for me. The Ryet's steeper angle, although noticeable, might be preferable for some riders who like a more aggressive posture.
Comfort is subjective, and individual preferences vary widely based on body type and riding style. The Ryet's lightweight design is appealing, but for me, the Fizik's superior comfort outweighs the added weight.
Conclusion: Which Saddle Should You Choose?
The Ryet saddle offers exceptional value at $38. Its lightweight carbon construction and comfortable 3D-printed material make it a compelling option for budget-conscious riders. However, the Fizik’s superior comfort and higher-quality materials justify the higher price tag, especially if purchased on sale or used.
Ultimately, the best saddle depends on individual preferences and needs. The Ryet is a fantastic budget-friendly option; the Fizik delivers superior comfort and build quality for the price. Consider factors like saddle width, weight, and desired riding position before making a purchase.
If you want a lightweight, affordable option to try 3D-printed technology, the Ryet is a no-brainer. But if comfort and build quality are top priorities, and budget isn't a huge concern, the Fizik is hard to beat.