This review chronicles a cyclist's 60,000-mile experience with Brooks saddles, a testament to their durability and comfort. Initially skeptical, the author eventually embraced Brooks, becoming a devoted user after years of long-distance cycling. This detailed account explores the pros and cons, covering various Brooks models, maintenance requirements, and the unique comfort they offer. From the B17 Special to the newer B66 and B67, the author shares firsthand insights gleaned from extensive use across diverse riding conditions.The review delves into the longevity and craftsmanship of Brooks saddles, highlighting their handcrafted nature in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter and the enduring design of the B17, a model that has withstood the test of time. Expect honest assessments of potential drawbacks, such as creaking and the need for occasional replacement, balanced against the unparalleled comfort and character these saddles develop over thousands of miles. This review provides a comprehensive guide for cyclists considering the investment in a Brooks saddle, offering valuable insights for informed decision-making.
Pros And Cons
- Comfortable for e-bikes (less pedaling)
- No break-in period required due to springs
- Absorbs bumps in the road
- Bolt can snap (this occurred at around 11,000 miles)
- Comfortable for long distances (up to 60,000 miles)
- Durable (lasts for years with proper care)
- Develops a unique patina over time
- Good suspension, especially when hitting potholes
- Clever design that molds to the rider's body
- Leather softens and changes shape if it gets wet
- Nose piece can wear out after extended use (27,000 miles in this case)
- Requires proper tension adjustment for optimal comfort
Read more: The 5 Best Bike Saddles for Triathlons
My Journey with Brooks Saddles
Initially, I was hesitant to purchase a Brooks saddle. I already owned a comfortable bike with a satisfactory saddle and didn't see the need for an upgrade. After all, I regularly cycled 40-50 miles without discomfort.
However, as my cycling mileage increased over the years, I decided to give a Brooks saddle a try. This decision proved to be a game-changer.
Since then, I've accumulated an impressive 60,000 miles on my Brooks saddles and I've become a devoted fan. I simply won't use any other saddle.
Maintenance and Durability
Proper maintenance is crucial for maximizing the lifespan of your Brooks saddle. Keeping the saddle properly tensioned, protecting it from rain with the provided cover, and avoiding prolonged exposure to water are essential.
I learned this the hard way when a race left my saddle soaked and softened the leather, slightly altering its shape.
Despite this incident, my saddles have proven remarkably durable. My B17 Special, with 27,000 miles of use, is nearing the end of its life, but that's a testament to its longevity.
Brooks Saddle Models: B17, Flyer, and B66/B67
I own several Brooks saddles, including the B17 Special, Flyer, and the newer B66 and B67 models. The B17 Special, known for its length, stretches about an inch over time.
The Flyer, ideal for e-bikes, has served me well despite a bolt snapping (which Brooks readily offered to repair).
The B66 and B67 models differ primarily in their mounting systems: one uses clamps, while the other uses standard rails.
Comfort, Suspension, and Design
Brooks saddles offer a unique comfort level. The leather conforms to your body shape over time, providing excellent support and a natural suspension system.
The design incorporates a hammock-like middle section, supported at the nose and rear, while the sides are shaped by the rider's thighs.
This clever design minimizes bouncing, providing exceptional comfort, especially when encountering bumps in the road.
Manufacturing and History
Brooks saddles are handcrafted locally in Birmingham's Jewellery Quarter, a location with a rich manufacturing history.
This commitment to local production contrasts with many competitors who utilize overseas manufacturing.
The B17 saddle's design has endured for over 130 years, surviving two World Wars, a testament to its enduring quality and design.
Breaking-in Period and Overall Impression
Unlike some saddles, the Brooks saddles, particularly the spring models, don't require a lengthy breaking-in period.
The natural suspension provided by the leather and (in spring models) the springs, absorbs bumps effectively.
However, a standard B7 might require 200-500 miles before reaching optimal comfort levels. After many miles and various models, I have nothing but praise for Brooks saddles.
Conclusion: Are Brooks Saddles Worth It?
Brooks saddles are an investment, both financially and in terms of time to break them in properly. They are not without potential issues like creaking (easily resolved with some grease), and they might require frequent replacement due to wear and tear.
However, the comfort they offer, especially during long rides and tours, is unparalleled. They develop a unique patina reflecting the journeys they've undertaken, creating a bond with the rider.
If you prioritize comfort, durability, and a saddle with character, then Brooks saddles are worth the expense. Their unique design, history, and quality make them an exceptional choice for serious cyclists.