This review delves into the Zefal Swan and Croozer Quick Release Fender Set, a budget-friendly option for cyclists seeking basic mudguard protection. Priced under $19, this set offers a lightweight yet surprisingly sturdy solution for commuters and casual riders. We'll examine the ease of installation, the effectiveness of the fenders in deflecting road spray, and the trade-offs inherent in its quick-release design. Specifically, we'll assess how well it performs in protecting against splashes, its impact on visibility with existing bike lights, and its suitability for different bike types.The review will explore both the advantages and disadvantages of this affordable fender set. We'll investigate whether the convenience of its quick-release system outweighs any compromises in protection or visibility. Ultimately, we aim to determine if the Zefal Swan and Croozer fenders represent a worthwhile investment for those seeking a simple, practical, and inexpensive way to keep clean during their rides.
Pros And Cons
- Quick release, easy to install and remove.
- Affordable (around $18-$19).
- Lightweight (approximately 210 grams total).
- Reflective quick release knob.
- Rear fender is angle adjustable.
- Provides good protection from rain and splashes for straight riding.
- Front fender is wide, covering the triangle area well.
- Blocks visibility of existing tail lights.
- May block the LED light on some rear lights.
- Requires sufficient space on the seat post; may not fit all bikes.
- Doesn't fully prevent water from splashing on legs during turns.
- May require adjustments to fit road bikes properly; may not fit all down tubes.
Read more: 5 Best Child Bike Fenders to Keep Your Little One Dry
Unboxing and First Impressions
The Zefal Swan and Croozer fender set arrived quickly and was surprisingly affordable, costing under $19 shipped from a UK seller on eBay. The packaging was simple but adequate, and the fenders themselves felt lightweight yet sturdy. The instructions were clear and easy to follow, a significant plus for a quick-release setup.
The set includes both a front (Croozer) and rear (Swan) fender. The lightweight design is a key selling point, with the Croozer weighing only 60 grams and the Swan 150 grams, totaling 210 grams. The reflective quick-release knobs are a nice safety feature for nighttime riding.
Installation Process
Installation is straightforward. The front fender attaches to the down tube using an included rubber strap, while the rear fender mounts to the seat post via a quick-release clamp. The rear fender's angle is adjustable, allowing for customization. The entire process is quick and easy, even for beginners.
The reviewer demonstrates the easy installation process for both front and rear fenders. The quick-release design allows for effortless attachment and removal, ideal for commuters who may not want to ride with them all the time.
Performance and Observations
The fenders provide decent protection from road spray, especially the rear fender, which covers a good portion of the tire. However, the quick-release design comes with some compromises. The rear fender obstructs visibility of existing rear lights, even with its reflective knob. Similarly, the front fender can interfere with front lights and reduces protection during turns.
The reviewer points out that while the fenders do a good job of deflecting water when riding straight, there is reduced protection during turns. Space constraints might make installation challenging on some bikes, particularly road bikes with limited clearance.
Conclusion and Final Verdict
Overall, the Zefal Swan and Croozer fender set offers good value for its price. The quick-release feature is convenient for commuters, and the lightweight design is a bonus. However, the limited protection during turns and potential visibility issues are notable drawbacks.
While it might not be a perfect solution for everyone, especially road cyclists, the Zefal set is a great option for hybrid and cross bikes offering a balance between protection and convenience. Its budget-friendly price makes it a worthy contender for riders looking for basic mudguard protection.
