Finding the perfect gravel bike shoes can be a challenge, with countless options flooding the market. This review cuts through the noise, offering an in-depth comparison of three top contenders for 2024: the Specialized S-Works Recon, the Specialized S-Works Recon Lace, and the Shimano RX8. We've put these shoes through rigorous testing across diverse terrains, evaluating their comfort, performance, durability, and overall value. Whether you prioritize superior stiffness, unparalleled comfort, or budget-friendly excellence, this review will guide you towards the ideal pair to elevate your gravel riding experience.This comparison explores the strengths and weaknesses of each model, highlighting key features and addressing potential drawbacks. From the sleek aesthetics and precise Boa dials of the Specialized Recons to the surprisingly comfortable laces of the Recon Lace and the impressive value of the Shimano RX8, we delve into the nuances of each design. Our comprehensive analysis, based on extensive real-world testing, will help you make an informed decision based on your individual needs and preferences.
Pros And Cons
- Good value
- Fairly stiff, light, responsive
- Good all-around shoe for everyday use
- Durable materials
- Comfortable due to less stiff sole
- Easier for hike-a-bike situations due to less stiff sole
- Aesthetics are 'good, not great'
- Hard to get in and out of
- Same look, fit, feel, styling as traditional Recon
- Most comfortable of the bunch
- Thrives on mixed terrain, long rides
- Laces distribute pressure evenly, eliminating hot spots
- Laces don't require mid-ride tightening
- Good heel hold
- Fast, stiff, responsive
- Good for everyday use and hike-a-bike situations
- High maintenance (cleaning laces)
- White color may show dirt easily
- Favorably received
- Modeled after S-Works seven road shoes
- Good looks
- Boa dials are easy to make micro adjustments
- Stiff, fast, responsive, comfortable
- Easy to clean
- Cable crosses over top of foot can dig in on long distances
Read more: 5 Best Vibram Cycling Shoes: A Buyer's Guide
Specialized S-Works Recon: The All-Around Champion
The Specialized S-Works Recons have been a favorite for three years, consistently receiving positive reviews. Their design is closely modeled after the popular S-Works Road shoes, offering a familiar fit and feel for road cyclists transitioning to gravel. They've been reinforced for durability, making them suitable for tougher terrain.
Aesthetically, the Recons are sleek and stylish, resembling the S-Works Seven road shoe but with added toe protection and rugged outsoles. The Boa dials are smooth and precise, providing a secure and comfortable fit. The cable routing looks clean and uncluttered.
Specialized S-Works Recon Lace: Comfort Meets Style
The Specialized S-Works Recon Lace, released last summer, offers the same fit and style as the traditional Recon but swaps the Boa dials for laces. This results in a cleaner, more minimalist aesthetic, almost indistinguishable from road shoes.
While laces might seem unconventional for gravel riding, they provide exceptional comfort and even pressure distribution. My experience suggests the laces are surprisingly functional and don't require constant readjustment during rides. The design is remarkably clean and stylish.
Shimano RX8: The Budget-Friendly Contender
The Shimano RX8s are a surprising value pick. While not as visually striking as the Specialized options, they offer excellent performance at a significantly lower price point. The stiffness is decent, the weight is reasonable, and the responsiveness is impressive for everyday riding.
However, the Boa dial placement and Velcro strap aren't as aesthetically pleasing, and the entry/exit isn't as convenient. Despite these minor drawbacks, the durability and comfort are hard to beat at this price.
On-the-Trail Performance and Comfort Comparison
Across hundreds to thousands of miles of gravel and mountain biking, the Recon Lace stood out as the most comfortable. The laces distribute pressure evenly, preventing hot spots. The traditional Recons are a close second, offering excellent stiffness and responsiveness, though the Boa cable placement can be a minor issue on longer rides.
The Shimano RX8, while less stiff, offered surprising comfort and durability, making them an excellent value option. They perform well on mixed terrain, though entry/exit could be smoother.
Conclusion: Finding the Right Gravel Shoe for You
The Specialized S-Works Recon offers top-tier performance, a premium look, and is an excellent all-around choice. The Recon Lace prioritizes comfort and a clean aesthetic but demands more maintenance. The Shimano RX8 delivers impressive value and performance, especially considering its significantly lower price point.
Ultimately, the best shoe depends on your priorities. If comfort and style are paramount, the Recon Lace is a winner, but if performance is top priority and you don’t mind the slightly less comfortable boa cable crossing the foot, the Recon is the way to go. For budget-conscious riders seeking excellent value, the Shimano RX8 is hard to ignore.
