This review dives deep into the SKS Edge Al Aluminum Mudguards, evaluating their performance, installation, and overall value. Manufactured in Germany from 100% aluminum, these mudguards come in 46mm and 56mm widths, offering compatibility with various tire sizes. We'll explore whether the price point, which varies significantly across regions (from approximately £30 to £50), justifies their quality and functionality. Particular attention will be paid to the installation process, a key area highlighted by reviewers as potentially challenging. A comparison with older SKS Chromoplastic models will also be made, highlighting the differences in design, mounting systems, and overall performance.This in-depth analysis will assess the effectiveness of the Edge Al mudguards in keeping riders dry in various weather conditions, from light rain to heavier downpours. We’ll examine the unique single-stay design and friction fit system, analyzing their impact on stability and ease of use. Ultimately, this review aims to determine whether the SKS Edge Al Aluminum Mudguards are a worthwhile investment for cyclists seeking reliable protection from road spray and a superior alternative to older mudguard designs.
Pros And Cons
- Good value for money
- High-quality impression
- Work well
- Stable once on the bike
- Unique and easy attachment system (friction fit)
- Solid aluminum construction
- Modern flat profile
- Keeps rider dry in wet weather and light rain
- Effective at keeping spray off the bike
- Difficult installation, especially the rear mudguard
- Requires careful measurement to ensure proper fit
- May require additional spacers for installation
- Water splashes from the sides when going through puddles at speed
Read more: 5 Best Child Bike Fenders to Keep Your Little One Dry
Product Overview and Pricing
The SKS Edge Al Aluminum Mudguards are manufactured in Germany and are constructed from 100% aluminum. They're available in 46mm and 56mm widths, catering to different tire sizes. Pricing varies regionally; in the UK, they cost around £50, while in the US, they're approximately $68 (also around £50). However, in Germany, they're significantly cheaper, at around €35 (approximately £30). This price difference highlights the impact of regional markets on product cost.
The 56mm version, as reviewed here, comfortably accommodates 45c tires. Although slightly larger tires might fit, vertical clearance could become an issue before horizontal clearance. The manufacturer suggests a 10mm difference between mudguard and tire size for optimal fit; hence, the 46mm version is better suited for 35c or 37c tires. This information is crucial for buyers to ensure compatibility with their bikes.
Installation Challenges and Solutions
Installation, particularly of the rear mudguard, proved challenging. The reviewer experienced difficulty fitting the mudguards to the chainstays, necessitating the use of plastic spacers to create additional clearance. Careful pre-installation measurements, especially at the seat stays, fork crown, and chainstays, are recommended to avoid similar problems.
The kit includes various fittings: a long bolt for the fork crown, standard bolts for mudguard attachment, and plastic spacers for fine-tuning. The reviewer used these spacers to achieve the correct fit in several areas, particularly near the bottom bracket shell and at the front. While the process was slightly difficult, the included components assisted in resolving fitting issues.
Comparison with SKS Chromoplastic Mudguards
The reviewer compares the SKS Edge Al with older SKS Chromoplastic mudguards. A key difference is the single-stay design of the Edge Al, offering a unique and simpler attachment system to the fork. The Chromoplastic mudguards provide either direct screw mounting to the fork or a quick-release plastic clip, whereas the Edge Al uses a friction fit system for easier centering and secure attachment.
The Edge Al’s friction fit system enables easy centering of the mudguards, enhancing usability. The single-stay design, while initially seeming less stable, proves surprisingly robust, requiring significant force to dislodge during riding. In contrast, the Chromoplastic mudguards were more prone to rubbing and easy dislodgement due to the quick-release system, requiring frequent readjustments.
Performance and Overall Assessment
The SKS Edge Al mudguards performed well in wet weather and light rain, effectively keeping spray off the rider. However, high-speed splashes through deep puddles may still result in wet feet, a common issue with many mudguards. The reviewer found the Edge Al’s performance superior to the older Chromoplastic models which experienced more rubbing.
Overall, the SKS Edge Al Aluminum Mudguards are highly recommended due to their excellent value, robust construction, and effective performance. The single-stay design and friction fit system offer enhanced usability and stability compared to older models. Minor installation challenges can be overcome with careful pre-planning and the use of included spacers. The modern aesthetic design is a bonus.
