Choosing the right flat pedals can significantly impact your mountain biking experience. This comparison dives deep into two popular and affordable options: the RaceFace Chester and the OneUp Components composite pedals. Both pedals are strong contenders in the sub-$50 market, boasting impressive performance and reliability. However, subtle differences in design and features lead to distinct riding experiences. We'll analyze weight, platform size, pin configuration, and overall grip to determine which pedal reigns supreme. This detailed head-to-head comparison will help you make an informed decision based on your individual riding style and preferences.This review stems from a personal transition to flat pedals after years of road cycling. Having initially used RaceFace Chesters, known for their affordability and performance, the author expanded the comparison to include OneUp Components' offering. We'll examine the minute weight discrepancies, analyze the practical differences in platform size and pin arrangement, and ultimately assess the impact these subtle differences have on grip, stability, and overall confidence on the trail. Prepare for a comprehensive breakdown that leaves no aspect unexplored, helping you choose the perfect pedal for your next mountain biking adventure.
Pros And Cons
- Amazing reviews
- Consistently perform well
- Relatively affordable
- Pedal strikes are less jarring than with alloy pedals due to composite material absorbing impact
- Smaller platform than 1up
- Shorter pins than 1up
- Requires more precise foot placement for stability
- More accurate weight listing than Race Face
- Larger platform
- Longer pins
- More pins for better grip
- More stable feeling, less precise foot placement needed
- Slightly stickier, requiring some adjustment period
Read more: 5 Best Child Bike Pedals for Smooth Rides
Initial Impressions and Weight Comparison
After years of road biking, I transitioned to mountain biking and quickly found that flat pedals were a game changer. I initially used the Race Face Chester pedals, widely praised for their performance and affordability.
Curiosity led me to compare them against the OneUp Components composite pedals, another popular choice in the same price range. A key initial consideration was weight. The Race Face Chesters, while advertised at 340 grams, actually weighed in at 357 grams. The OneUp pedals, listed at 355 grams, tipped the scales at 359 grams – a negligible difference in practical terms.
Both pedals offer a similar platform size (around 4 inches wide and 4.5 inches long), though the Race Face Chester's usable length was slightly shorter due to its design. The Chester's stood taller at 15mm versus OneUp's 13.3mm, although including pin height, they were practically equal.
Platform Size, Pin Design, and Grip
While both pedals were advertised as similarly sized, the OneUp pedal offered a more substantial platform for foot placement in practice. The pin design also differed significantly. The Race Face Chester's feature eight pins per side, arranged in a two-by-four pattern. The OneUp pedals boast ten pins per side, with a more distributed pattern (three front, three middle, four back) that provides improved contact points.
This difference in pin arrangement and overall pin count is crucial. The OneUp's broader pin distribution offered noticeably better grip regardless of foot position on the pedal. The OneUp pedals consistently provided more secure contact.
This greater grip translated to a more confident feel on the trail. I felt less constrained in my foot placement with the OneUp pedals, while the Chester's required more precise positioning to feel secure.
Ride Feel and Overall Performance
During a side-by-side test (one Chester, one OneUp pedal), the difference in platform size and pin distribution became evident. The OneUp's larger area and more pins provided a more planted feel, even with slightly less precise foot placement.
While the Race Face Chester's performed well and offered excellent grip, I found myself needing to more carefully position my foot for optimal stability. The OneUp pedal's superior grip reduced this concern.
The increased grip with OneUp was a definite plus, although it required a short adjustment period. The initial stickiness took some getting used to, compared to the Chester's more forgiving feel.
Conclusion: Which Pedal Reigns Supreme?
Both the Race Face Chester and OneUp Composite pedals are excellent options in the sub-$50 range. The Race Face Chester is a proven performer, offering consistent, reliable grip and performance. Its smaller size might be better for those who prefer a more precise feel.
However, the OneUp Composite pedal edged out the Chester in this comparison. Its larger platform, superior pin distribution and resulting enhanced grip make it a compelling choice for most riders. The slightly increased initial stickiness is a minor trade-off for the overall improved confidence and stability.
Ultimately, the best pedal depends on individual preferences. But for overall performance and value at the $50 price point, the OneUp Composite pedal deserves the win.